Perspectives on church government

Five Views of Church Polity.

Perspectives on church government

Episcopalian structure James White: Plural Elder-Led I have mixed feelings about this book. It was informative, but uneven. My enjoyment and understanding rose and fell depending upon the author!

Some may see this diversity as a strength, but I think the book would have been more effective if all authors defended their view as being the most Scriptural.

This would have leveled the playing field and probably would have led to more interaction with the texts that others used in their presentations. Akin, Garrett and White all presented a form of Congregationalism.

One could argue that having three presentations devoted to one view is unbalanced or unnecessary. A chapter attempting to defend a non-denominational model could have been worthwhile addition.

Conclusion Does this book succeed? It depends what you want from it. If you want to read authors all arguing for their position from Scripture, this may not be the best book to buy.

If you want introductions to some of the key issues and positions, and to see how others would respond to these presentations, this would be worth looking into. Christians Investigating Church Polity Shelves: After each presentation there are rebuttals from each contributer.

I found that it was refreshing to hear each argument clearly presented from biblical, historical, practical, and experiential angles. The rebuttals were not costic, but honest and charitable.

Perspectives on church government

At the end of the book I came away with a greater understanding that there probably is one clear way of polity that God knows, but He decided NOT to be too clear about it Scripturally to us. Therefore, church polity is more of a dynamic that each church must decide based on biblical convictions.

Popular Topics

Some things are clear i. Therefore, instead of being bound by non-essentials that divide, churches should stand on what is clear biblically then be free in their interpretation of implementation.

Also, church history arguments were presented in each camp to support their views but caused the most division between their viewpoints; however, there was the most agreement when each used Scripture to describe their viewpoint commonality until they went further to apply how to implement what they found in the Scriptures.Perspectives on Church Government - eBook () by Chad Owen Brand & R.

Stanton Norman, eds.4/4(1). Perspectives on Church Government. 1 January Religion; A model may sometimes be referred to as “polity”, the definition of a polity is “the form of government of a nation, state, church, or organization.

” (The Free Dictionary n. d.) Each model will be discussed and defended by an author, and later that chapter is rebutted by. Perspectives on Church Government presents in counterpoint form the basic models of church government which have developed over the course of church history with a view toward determining which is most faithful to Scripture.

Each chapter will be written by a prominent person from within each tradition—with specific guidelines dealing with the. In Perspectives on Church Government, a similar wedge is driven between plural eldership and full-scale congregationalism.

See a Problem?

In this volume Daniel Akin defends a single-pastor-led polity, James Leo Garrett presents a pastor- and deacon-led polity, and James R. White defends a plural-elder-led church. The format of this book follows the beneficial varying-perspectives-on-one-subject approach of several books that enables readers to evaluate the arguments set forth by the differing positions.

Perspectives on church government

In this case the subject is church polity. After an introductory chapter by the editors, the following five chapters first present an extended argument for a particular perspective and [ ]. In Perspectives on Church Government, editors Chad Owen Brand and R.

Stanton Norman seek to facilitate a discussion that will engage these questions by providing the reader with a defense of the “classic positions on the matter of governing the church” (23), which include the Congregational model, the Presbyterian model, and the Episcopal.

Perspectives on Church Government | Baptist Theology